Article Contents (Estimated Reading Time - 8 mins 23 secs)

In recent years, there has been a surge in demand for defined benefit pension transfer, with many people wanting to transfer out of their defined benefit pension and into a defined contribution pension or a lump sum payment. 

This has been driven in part by the increased flexibility and control offered by defined contribution pensions and concerns about the security and sustainability of defined benefit pensions in the face of a changing economic and demographic landscape.

However, defined benefit pension transfers can be complex and risky, and the UK government and financial regulators have introduced a number of rules and regulations to try to protect consumers from the potential dangers of transferring out of a defined benefit pension. Learn more about this topic in one of our YouTube videos below.


The DB Pension Transfer Rules Are Becoming Increasingly Restrictive

Defined benefit pension transfer has a long and complicated history in the UK. Defined benefit pensions, also known as final salary pensions, are a type of pension plan in which the employer guarantees a specific retirement benefit to the employee, typically based on their salary and years of service.

For many years, defined benefit pensions were the dominant form of a workplace pension in the UK. However, in the 1980s and 1990s, many companies began to close their defined benefit pension schemes to new members and instead offer defined contribution pensions, which do not guarantee a specific retirement benefit but instead involve contributions to a pension pot that is invested and the eventual retirement income depends on the investment returns.

In 2015, the UK government introduced new rules requiring anyone with a defined benefit pension worth more than £30,000 to seek financial advice before transferring out. In addition, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has introduced a number of new rules governing the conduct of financial advisers and pension providers when dealing with defined benefit pension transfers.

Despite these regulations, there have been concerns that some financial advisers have been encouraging people to transfer out of their defined-benefit pensions when it is not in their best interests to do so. This has led to calls for even stricter rules and regulations to be put in place to protect consumers.

The UK’s tight regulation around defined benefit pension transfers is causing firms in the sector to shirk, according to a report by the Financial Times. Last year, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) introduced stricter rules for advisers when transferring pensions. 

This has caused several firms to shut down or exit the market altogether. Those that remain are more cautious in advising clients, fearing they may face complaints or regulatory action down the line. As a result, customers who want to transfer their pensions are facing long wait times for advice or are being told by firms that they are unwilling to take on their business. Critics say the regulatory clampdown is causing unintended consequences, with many pension holders unable to access the best deals.

The DB Advice Firm Shrinks Due to the Complexity of Final Salary Pension Transfer

In recent years, the number of firms offering defined benefit (DB) pension advice has decreased. The reasons for this include increased regulatory scrutiny, rising professional indemnity insurance costs, and concerns about potential miss-selling claims. As a result, some clients looking to transfer their DB pension to a defined contribution (DC) scheme may find it harder to find a suitable adviser.

DB pension schemes provide a guaranteed income in retirement, but they can be expensive for employers to fund. As a result, many firms have closed their schemes to new members or frozen benefits for existing members. This has led to a surge in demand for DB pension transfer advice as members look to take advantage of high transfer values and greater control over their pension savings.

However, transferring a DB pension is a complex decision with potential risks and benefits that need to be carefully considered. In particular, clients need to be aware of the risks of transferring out of a guaranteed income and the potential impact on their retirement income in the future.

Advisers who provide DB pension transfer advice need to have specialist knowledge and experience, as well as the appropriate qualifications and regulatory permissions. However, in recent years, some advisers have faced regulatory action or complaints related to DB pension transfers, which has increased the scrutiny on this area of advice.

As a result, some firms have chosen to exit the market or reduce their exposure to DB pension transfers. This has left some clients struggling to find suitable advisers or facing higher fees for advice.

Clients looking for DB pension transfer advice should ensure they choose an adviser with the appropriate qualifications, experience, and regulatory permissions. They should also be prepared to pay higher fees for advice, as the cost of professional indemnity insurance has increased for advisers operating in this area.

The Cost of DB Pension Transfer Advice Has Increased Due to the New Regulation of Final Salary Pension

In recent years, the price of advice pension transfer reports provided by DB pension advice firms has increased significantly. This trend has caused concern among consumers, financial advisors, and regulatory bodies, who are questioning the rationale behind the price hikes.

One of the primary reasons for the increase in prices is the growing complexity of pension transfer advice. In recent years, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has tightened its regulations around pension transfer advice, making it more difficult for advisors to provide this service. As a result, many firms have had to invest in more training and technology to keep up with the changing requirements. This investment has led to higher costs, which have been passed on to clients in the form of higher fees.

Additionally, the risk associated with providing pension transfer advice has increased, leading many firms to charge higher fees to compensate for this. With more and more clients looking to transfer their pensions, the potential for errors or mis-spelling has increased, leaving advisors exposed to significant liability. This has led many firms to increase their fees to cover the cost of insurance and compliance, which can be substantial.

Finally, the supply and demand of pension transfer advice have also played a role in the rising costs. As more consumers seek advice on pension transfers, the demand for this service has increased. However, the number of qualified advisors in this area has not kept pace with this demand, leading to a shortage of supply. This has allowed firms to charge higher fees, as clients have fewer options available to them.

The rise in prices for advice pension transfer reports provided by DB pension advice firms can be attributed to a combination of factors, including increased complexity, higher risk, and supply and demand dynamics. While the higher fees may be a concern for consumers, it is important to remember that pension transfer advice is a complex and high-risk area, and firms need to invest in the right tools, technology, and compliance to provide this service effectively.

PI Insurance Is Getting More Expensive

Pension transfers can be a complex process, requiring expertise and experience to ensure the best possible outcome for clients. Independent Financial Advisors (IFAs) play a vital role in helping clients navigate the pension transfer process, providing advice and guidance on the options available to them.

However, with the potential for errors or omissions in the advice given, it is important for IFAs to have professional indemnity (PI) insurance in place to protect themselves and their clients from any financial losses that may occur as a result of mistakes.

In the UK, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) requires all financial advisors to have PI insurance as a condition of their authorization. This insurance provides cover for claims made against the advisor for any negligent advice or breach of professional duty.

When it comes to pension transfers, the stakes can be high. If a client is advised to transfer their pension to a scheme that is not suitable for their needs, they could face significant financial losses in the form of lower investment returns or increased fees.

In such cases, PI insurance can provide a safety net for both the advisor and the client. If a claim is made against the advisor for negligence or breach of duty, the insurance will cover any financial losses suffered by the client as a result of the advice given.

The cost of PI insurance can vary depending on the level of coverage required and the specific risks associated with the advisor’s business. However, it is generally considered to be a necessary expense for any IFA providing advice on pension transfers.

In addition to having PI insurance, IFAs also have a duty of care to their clients. This means that they must act in their client’s best interests, provide clear and accurate advice, and disclose any potential conflicts of interest that may arise.

PI insurance aims to provide peace of mind for both the advisor and the client. By ensuring that they have appropriate insurance in place, IFAs can protect themselves against potential financial losses and maintain their reputation as trusted professionals in the pension transfer market.

Professional indemnity insurance is a crucial aspect of the pension transfer process for both IFAs and their clients. Providing a safety net in case of any errors or omissions helps ensure that the process is as smooth and successful as possible for all parties involved.

Cameron James, UK Expat Financial Planning – Your Trustworthy Pension Transfer Specialist

At Cameron James, we’re here to help you transfer your pension. With over a decade of experience in the industry, our team of expert financial planners has assisted expatriates from all over the world.

We are fully qualified and knowledgeable in the area of transferring pensions to an International SIPP, especially for US residents. Our goal is to provide clear, regulated, and transparent advice to all of our clients, with no hidden fees.

We have a sophisticated system in place to help manage your cash flow, and our senior management team has a wealth of experience in serving the needs of expatriates. We’re dedicated to providing you with the best possible advice and support.

Take the first step towards a secure financial future, and book a free initial consultation with one of our IFAs today!


Dominic James Murray

My career in financial services began in 2010 during my Bachelor of Science (BSc) Undergraduate degree at Aston University in England. The degree required me to spend a year abroad working with an established organisation.

Read Our Google Reviews
5.0 Star Rating

Book Your Free Appointment

✅ Talk with an Experienced Adviser at the time convenient for you, to understand your options.
📈 Our Adviser will send a Free Advice Report for you to make an informed decision.

uk pension transfer specialist dominic murray
Reach Us